All Cast
Martin Herlihy
Martin
John Higgins
John
Ben Marshall
Ben
Conan O'Brien
Farley
Bowen Yang
Deetch Nordwind
Megan Stalter
Lisa
X Mayo
Taylor
Nichole Sakura
Amy
Cedric Yarbrough
Gates
Chloe Troast
Poppy
Sunita Mani
Tricia
Jordan Mendoza
Dylan
Liz Demmon
Julia
William Banks
Banks
Jamie Linn Watson
Jane
Gaten Matarazzo
Self
John Goodman
Narrator (voice)
Maximo Masefield
Young Martin
Marcel Nahapetian
Young John
Trevor Noble
Young Ben
Carmen Christopher
Carmen
Rick Espaillat
Captain Jean Pierre Le Roche
Stephen Starkweather
Priest
Keya Hamilton
Church Woman
Beth Corvino
New Church Member
Boston Pierce
Teen Boy with Beer
Cruz Abelita
Teen Boy with Beer
Vince Canlas
Appraiser
Scott Dixon
Guard (uncredited)