Jennifer Schwalbach Smith
Betsy
Justin Long
Brandon St. Randy
Jean-Pierre Nutini
Auditioner
Lena Cheney
Auditioning Girl
Danielle Fortwangler
Stripper
Milos Milicevic
Construction Foreman
James W. Smith
Indecisive Customer
Tyler Labine
Drunk Customer
Tisha Campbell
Delaney's Wife
Lauren Miller Rogen
Moaner and Groaner
Jackson Nunn
Club Owner's Friend (uncredited)