All Cast
Angela Bettis
May
Jeremy Sisto
Adam
Anna Faris
Polly
James Duval
Blank
Nichole Hiltz
Ambrosia
Kevin Gage
Papa
Merle Kennedy
Mama
Chandler Riley Hecht
Young May
Rachel David
Petey
Nora Zehetner
Hoop
Will Estes
Chris
Roxanne Day
Buckle
Samantha Adams
Lucille
Brittney Lee Harvey
Diedre
Connor Matheus
Kindergarten Boy
Mike McKee
Optometrist
Ken Davitian
Foreign Doctor
Bret Roberts
Distraught Man at Veterinarian Office
Traci Burr
Short Girl
Jude McVay
Zombie
Tricia Kelly
Amy
Norwood Cheek
Guy on Bench
Jesse Hlubik
Jack
Jennifer Grant
Jill
Lucky McKee
Guy Making Out in the Elevator (uncredited)