All Cast
Payson Lewis
Peter Simonds
Jonah Platt
Jason McConnell
Lindsay Pearce
Ivy Robinson
Katie Stevens
Nadia McConnell
Nathan Parrett
Matt Lloyd
Stephanie Andersen
Sister Chantelle/Virgin Mary
Alissa-Nicole Koblentz
Claire
John Griffin
Priest
Casey Hayden
Lucas Carter
Caitlin Ary
Tanya Garrett/Cherub
Katherine Washington
Kyra/Cherub
Reesa Ishiyama
Diane Lee
Christopher Higgins
Zack
Kelsey Hainlen
Rory