Whitney Call
Robert Failure Gladstone / Charlotte / Temperance
Matthew Meese
Captain Evander Lillianquist / Willy / Flour Man / Jeff
Jason Gray
Chesterton / Doctor / Proprietor / Kit Carson
Natalie Madsen
Aveline / Madam Molly
Stephen Meek
Elijah / William / Thirsty Man
Stacey Harkey
Terrence / Clarence / Fan #2 / The Ringmaster
Jeremy Warner
Hank / The Lion
Adam Berg
Percival / Polio Joe / Henry / Billy / Mime
James Perry
Angus / Julian / Johnny River / Fan #1 / Porch Man / Papa