All Cast
Rachael Leigh Cook
Erin
Sam Page
Sam
Bailey Stender
Debbie
Patrick Thomas O'Brien
Chuck
T. Mychael Rambo
Santa
Kathryn Fumie
Maria
Rod Kasai
Taylor
Mika Flanagan
Olivia
Melinda Kordich
Diana
Chase Marcotte
Jonah
Jim Cunningham
Lou
Sarah Agnew
Mayor
Greta Oglesby
NP General Counsel
Ahmed Mawas
Archie
Agatha Rae Pokrzywinski
Bakery Worker
Rae Dastoor
Bakery Owner
Jake Leider
Radio Intern
Christina Goltare
Town Square Shopper (uncredited)
Gwen Ruhoff
Elf Council member (uncredited)
Dawan Scott
Tree Ceremony Attendee (uncredited)
Laura Judson
Santa's Elf (uncredited)
Amy Jo Schmidt
Elf Council Member (uncredited)