All Cast
Melissa Joan Hart
Ella
Presley Allard
Mary Bailey
Olivia Scriven
Veronica
Connor McMahon
Willard Simms
Luca Thunberg
Sammy Bailey
Laura Adamo
Cordelia
JaNae Armogan
Police Woman
Isabella Astbury
Young Mary Bailey
Dana Fradkin
Jennifer
Patrick Ludlow
Background performer (Police)
Barbara Saxberg
Judge Bristol
Michael Gordin Shore
Angus
Pierre Simpson
Pastor McCall
Paulyne Wei
Celine
