Edward Norton
Bill Kincaid / Brady Kincaid
Susan Sarandon
Daisy Kincaid
Richard Dreyfuss
Pug Rothbaum
Lucy DeVito
Anne Greenstein
Kent Jude Bernard
Philosophy Student
Amelia Campbell
Maggie Harmon
Pruitt Taylor Vince
Big Joe Sharpe
Ty Burrell
Professor Sorenson
Lee Wilkof
Professor Nathan Levy
Lisa Benavides
Suzie Feinman
Steven E. Williams
Synagogue Parishioner (uncredited)
Maggie Siff
Rabbi Zimmerman
Ken Cheeseman
Jimmy Fuller
Jim Henry
Policeman (uncredited)