All Cast
Jena Malone
Mary Cummings
Mandy Moore
Hilary Faye
Macaulay Culkin
Roland
Patrick Fugit
Patrick
Eva Amurri
Cassandra
Heather Matarazzo
Tia
Martin Donovan
Pastor Skip
Mary-Louise Parker
Lillian
Chad Faust
Dean
Elizabeth Thai
Veronica
Valerie Bertinelli
Self
Birkett Turton
Mitch
Julia Arkos
PE Coach
Donna White
Trudy Mason
James Caldwell
Hairdresser
Nicki Clyne
Guitar Player
Aaron Douglas
Paramedic
Patricia Drake
Dean's Mother
Brent Fidler
Church Man
Jay Hilliker
Waiter / Host
John Innes
Pastor
Greg Kean
Dean's Father
Joe MacLeod
Lead Singer
Althea McAdam
Church Wife
Thomas Plustwik
Carpenter / Jesus
Syndie Skeeles
3 Year Old Mary