All Cast
Tom Everett Scott
Josh
Mark-Paul Gosselaar
Cooper
Poppy Montgomery
Rachel
Lochlyn Munro
Cliff
Alyson Hannigan
Lucy
Randy Pearlstein
Buckley
Corey Page
Matt
Jason Segel
Kyle
Linda Cardellini
Kelly
Mari Morrow
Kristin
Mark Carapezza
Hank
Jeff Tarpley
Jerry
Aeryk Egan
Pickle
Judyann Elder
Guidance Counselor
Dave Ruby
Zeke
Wynn Irwin
Sonny
John Aprea
Mr. Frederickson
Michael O'Hagan
Chemistry Professor
Nancy Linehan Charles
Anatomy Professor
Shelley Malil
Biology Professor
Ann Fairlie
Mrs. Boison
Paul Collins
Professor Durkheim
Johnny Dark
Henry The Drunk
Daniel Villarreal
Roberto
Annie O'Donnell
Merrilee
P.J. Ochlan
Boy Bookworm
Michael Rivkin
'Shhh'-ing Student
Peter James Smith
Calculus Seatmate
Kurt Loder
Self
Mary Stein
Irritated Woman
Brian Howe
Frank
Patrick Thomas O'Brien
Priest
Rueben Grundy
Guy
Steve Mackall
TV Show Host
Cory Oliver
Pam
Zoaunne LeRoy
Cafeteria Worker
Kenn Michael
Luke