All Cast
Elizabeth Rice
Lindsay
Thomas Dekker
Aidan
Kelly Blatz
Dylan
Laura Allen
Trish
Adam Goldberg
Roy
Rumer Willis
Natalie
Margo Harshman
Sadie
Britt Robertson
Claire
Jared Harris
Bernard
Steven Culp
Pastor joe
Amanda Babin
Molly
Shiloh Fernandez
Sean
Mark A. Cummins
Classroom Teacher
David Ariniello
Paul
Tim Colmus
Neighbor
Tyler Gatton
Neighbor Kid
Caitlin Gold
Julie
Jamie Linck O'Brien
Kelly
Jonathan Orcutt
Sheriff Cooper
Candace Hammer
Mary
Jim Barbour
Townsman
Larry Carter
Teacher
John Doty
Paramedic
Paul Fahrenkopf
Worshiper
Ponch Fenwick
Townsmen
Pete Karas
Worshiper