All Cast

Jason Alexander

Jason Alexander

Elf (Voice)

James Eckhouse

James Eckhouse

Dad (voice)

Don Knotts

Don Knotts

Kris (voice)

Shelley Long

Shelley Long

Mom (voice)

Mae Whitman

Mae Whitman

Beth (voice)

Jess Harnell

Jess Harnell

Toymaker / Santa / Aged Elf (voice)

Richard Steven Horvitz

Richard Steven Horvitz

Cheddar (voice)

Aaron Spann

Aaron Spann

Tommy (voice)