All Cast
Gerard Griesbaum
Dennis L. Rader (1974)
Eric Gerleman
Dennis L. Rader (2004)
Victoria Ullmann
Miss Hatch
Shyla Fernandes
Vicki
Danielle Petty
Laci Peterson
Michael Barbour
Jack
Nola Roeper
Paula Rader (2004)
Erin Young
Nancy
Emelle
Dolores
Crystal Nelson
Paula Rader (1974)
Christian Behm
Pastor (2004) / Deputy (1974)
Ricky Love
Pastor (1974)
Yannis Bariamis
Detective
Micah Moses
Dennis
Max Nikoff
Warehouse Worker
Robert Fischer
Mr. Hatch
Bud Watson
Detective #2
