All Cast

Allison Williams

Allison Williams

Peter Pan

Christopher Walken

Christopher Walken

Captain Hook

Christian Borle

Christian Borle

George Darling / Smee

Kelli O'Hara

Kelli O'Hara

Mrs. Darling

Taylor Louderman

Taylor Louderman

Wendy Darling

Minnie Driver

Minnie Driver

Adult Wendy Darling / Narrator

Jake Lucas

Jake Lucas

John Darling

John Allyn

John Allyn

Michael Darling

Alanna Saunders

Alanna Saunders

Tiger Lily

Caitlin Houlahan

Caitlin Houlahan

Jane Darling

Jason Gotay

Jason Gotay

Tootles

Alan H. Green

Alan H. Green

Cookson

Jacob Guzman

Jacob Guzman

Twin 1

David Guzman

David Guzman

Twin 2

F. Michael Haynie

F. Michael Haynie

Slightly

Austin Lesch

Austin Lesch

Bill Jukes

Chris McCarrell

Chris McCarrell

Nibs

Michael Park

Michael Park

Cecco

Bryce Ryness

Bryce Ryness

Starkey

Ryan Steele

Ryan Steele

Curly

Chris Sullivan

Chris Sullivan

Noodler

Ryan Andes

Ryan Andes

Admiral Crichton

Dyllón Burnside

Dyllón Burnside

Prickles

John Arthur Greene

John Arthur Greene

Robert Mullins / Islander

Michael Hartung

Michael Hartung

Sniffler

Garett Hawe

Garett Hawe

Patches

Dominique Kelley

Dominique Kelley

Ensemble

Marty Lawson

Marty Lawson

Ensemble

Gary Milner

Gary Milner

The Vicar / Islander

Michael Munday

Michael Munday

Ensemble

Andrew Pirozzi

Andrew Pirozzi

Ensemble

Daniel Quadrino

Daniel Quadrino

Bunting

T. Oliver Reid

T. Oliver Reid

Oliver Shreeks / Islander

C. J. Tyson

C. J. Tyson

Ensemble

Matt Wall

Matt Wall

Skylights / Islander

Keenan D. Washington

Keenan D. Washington

Ensemble

Charlie Williams

Charlie Williams

Ensemble

Alex Wong

Alex Wong

Ensemble

Helen Anker

Helen Anker

Dancer / Chorus

Stephanie Kim

Stephanie Kim

Dancer / Chorus

Sarah O'Gleby

Sarah O'Gleby

Dancer / Chorus

Kathryn Terza

Kathryn Terza

Mermaid / understudy Tiger Lily

James Brown III

James Brown III

Islander / Pirate

Henry Gottfried

Henry Gottfried

understudy Peter Pan/swing for lost boys