Allison Williams
Peter Pan
Christopher Walken
Captain Hook
Christian Borle
George Darling / Smee
Taylor Louderman
Wendy Darling
Minnie Driver
Adult Wendy Darling / Narrator
John Allyn
Michael Darling
Alanna Saunders
Tiger Lily
Caitlin Houlahan
Jane Darling
F. Michael Haynie
Slightly
Ryan Andes
Admiral Crichton
John Arthur Greene
Robert Mullins / Islander
Gary Milner
The Vicar / Islander
T. Oliver Reid
Oliver Shreeks / Islander
Matt Wall
Skylights / Islander
Keenan D. Washington
Ensemble
Helen Anker
Dancer / Chorus
Stephanie Kim
Dancer / Chorus
Sarah O'Gleby
Dancer / Chorus
Kathryn Terza
Mermaid / understudy Tiger Lily
James Brown III
Islander / Pirate
Henry Gottfried
understudy Peter Pan/swing for lost boys