Bathsheba Garnett
The Witch
Sarah Stephens
The Witch, Young
Daniel Malik
Black Phillip (voice)
Vivien Moore
Lead Coven Witch
Madlen Sopadzhiyan
Coven Witch
Paul Kenworthy
Militia Man 1
Mark Millmna
Militia Man 2
Phillip Wynne
Wampanoag Man
Annawon Weeden
Wampanoag Man
Michael O'Hare
Pipe Smoker
Heather Huntington Stewart
Chamber Pot Woman
Jeff Smith
Nobelman (uncredited)