Michelle Williams
Charity Barnum
Rebecca Ferguson
Jenny Lind
Yahya Abdul-Mateen II
W. D. Wheeler
Natasha Liu Bordizzo
Deng Yan
Paul Sparks
James Gordon Bennett
Sam Humphrey
Charles Stratton
Austyn Johnson
Caroline Barnum
Cameron Seely
Helen Barnum
Eric Anderson
Mr. O'Malley
Ellis Rubin
Young P. T. Barnum
Skylar Dunn
Young Charity Hallett
Daniel Everidge
Lord of Leeds
Yusaku Komori
Chang Bunker
Linda Marie Larson
Mrs. Stratton
Byron Jennings
Mr. Carlyle
Fredric Lehne
Benjamin Hallett
Kathryn Meisle
Hannah Hallett
Gayle Rankin
Queen Victoria
Sawyer Niehaus
Ballerina #2
Shuler Hensley
Lead Protestor
James Andrew O'Connor
Fireman
Michael Barra
Stage Manager
Shannon Freyer
Jenny Lind Admirer #1
Kevin Dwane
Jenny Lind Admirer #2
Sandi DeGeorge
Jenny Lind Admirer #3
Tony Neil Butler
Royal Escort
Frances Emily Schramm
Laundry Woman
Kenneth Wong Chan
Human Cannonball
Stacey Alyse Cohen
Theatre Goer #1
Tim Wilson
Theatre Goer #2
Jonathon Culver
Theatre Goer #3
Jillian Braithwaite
Panhandler
Adam Haas Hunter
Protester
Martha Nichols
Woman in Gold
Jonathan Redavid
Dancer Oddity #1
Shannon Holtzapffel
Dancer Oddity #2
Jeremy Hudson
Dancer Oddity #3
Taylor James
Dancer Oddity #4
Chelsea Caso
Dancer Oddity #5
Caoife Coleman
Dancer Oddity #6
Mishay Petronelli
Dancer Oddity #7
Khasan Brailsford
Ensemble Dancer #1
Alex Wong
Ensemble Dancer #2
Julius Anthony Rubio
Ensemble Dancer #3
Vincent-Olivier Noiseux
Ensemble Dancer #4
DeAnna Walters
Ensemble Dancer #5
Ilia Jessica Castro
Ensemble Dancer #6
Najla Gilliam
Ensemble Dancer #7
Christina Glur
Ensemble Dancer #8
Emerson Tate Alexander
Pointe Ballerina #1
Victoria Llodra
Pointe Ballerina #2
Louise Hindsbo
Pointe Ballerina #3
Laci Justice
Pointe Ballerina #4
GiaNina Paolantonio
Pointe Ballerina #5
Rachel Quiner
Pointe Ballerina #6
Madison Smith
Pointe Ballerina #7
Brando
Pointe Ballerina #8
Daniel 'Cloud' Campos
Dancing Bartender #1
Rod Roberts
Dancing Bartender #2
James Babson
Additional Voices (voice)
Loren Allred
Jenny Lind (singing voice)
Brayden Titus
Upper-Class Child (uncredited)