All Cast
Liam James
Solomon
Sarah Steele
Diwata
Austin P. McKenzie
Howie
Janeane Garofalo
Marie
Kal Penn
James
Roger Bart
Principal Bellingham
Wendi McLendon-Covey
Joan
Kimberly Williams-Paisley
Susan
Skylar Astin
Walter Healy
Sarah Baker
Miss Riggi
Darren Criss
Darren Criss
Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth
Cristina Franco
Oksana
Ryan Lee
Mark
Edgar Arreola
Arnett
Karen Beyer
Persuasive Speaking Judge
Orlette Cutrer
Teacher
Lucy DeVito
Lucy
Sara Thomas Easley
Nervous Freshman Girl
Sam Furman
Student
Angel Giuffria
Girl in Motorized Wheelchair
Gideon Glick
Gideon
Jessy Hughes
Goth Girl
Bradley K. Jones
Student
Jerry Leggio
Ted
Karen Kaia Livers
Nurse
Anna Margaret
Casey
David Militello
Plump Boy
Lin-Manuel Miranda
The Genie
Tara Shay Montgomery
Young Drag Queen
Robert Peters
Coach Pemberton
Nicholas James Reilly
Holy Ghost Junior
Bryce Romero
Short Kid
Jeremy Rowley
Gary Crenshaw
Ben Sanders
Student
Logan Shroyer
Hot Debater
Amitoz Singh
DI Boy
Lester Speight
Scary Bouncer
George Thagard
Mayor
Sloane Warren
Fiona Crenshaw
