Gina Rodriguez
Mary (voice)
Zachary Levi
Joseph (voice)
Keegan-Michael Key
Dave (voice)
Kelly Clarkson
Leah (voice)
Anthony Anderson
Zach (voice)
Kris Kristofferson
Old Donkey (voice)
Ving Rhames
Thaddeus (voice)
Gabriel Iglesias
Rufus (voice)
Patricia Heaton
Edith (voice)
Kristin Chenoweth
Abby (voice)
Christopher Plummer
King Herod (voice)
Tracy Morgan
Felix (voice)
Oprah Winfrey
Deborah (voice)
Mariah Carey
Rebecca (voice)
Fred Tatasciore
Melchior / Inn keeper #1 / Pottery Vendor (voice)
Kari Wahlgren
Additional Voices (voice)
Gregg Berger
Inn Keeper #3 (voice)
Joel Osteen
Caspar (voice)
Roger Craig Smith
Chamberlain / Inn Keeper #5 (voice)
William Townsend
Horse / Goat (voice)
Stephen Apostolina
Additional Voices (voice)
Kirk Baily
Additional Voices (voice)
David Cowgill
Additional Voices (voice)
June Christopher
Additional Voices (voice)
Eddie Frierson
Additional Voices (voice)
Rif Hutton
Additional Voices (voice)
Mona Marshall
Additional Voices (voice)
Caitlin McKenna
Additional Voices (voice)
Scott Menville
Additional Voices (voice)
Warren Sroka
Additional Voices (voice)
Pepper Sweeney
Additional Voices (voice)
Grant George
Additional Voices (voice)
Bridget Hoffman
Additional Voices (voice)
Moira Quirk
Additional Voices (voice)
Michelle Ruff
Additional Voices (voice)
Joseph Sanfelippo
Additional Voices (voice)
Justin Shenkarow
Additional Voices (voice)
