Sam Hennings
Benjamin Steed
Brenda Strong
Mary Ann Steed
Alexander Carroll
Nathan Steed
Tiffany Dupont
Lydia McBride
Brighton Hertford
Melissa Steed / Narrator
Kimberly Varadi
Becca Steed
Kathryn Firago
Hannah McBride
Jim Grimshaw
Josiah McBride
Jonathan Scarfe
Joseph Smith
Edward Albert
Martin Harris
Jordan Rose Tarter
Sophronia Smith
Anne Sward
Lucy Mack Smith
Sara Jade Woodhouse
Will Murdock
Jonathan Quint
Mark Cooper
Phillip DeVona
David Murdock
Marcus Hester
Caleb Jackson
Emily Podleski
Jessica Roundy
Wayne Grace
First Land Agent
Charles Howerton
Second Land Agent
Sheri Mann Stewart
First Woman
Marc Macaulay
Land Speculator
Joseph Wilkins
Second Member
James Van Harper
Wagon Master
Terry Haskell
First Troublemaker
Jarron Vosburg
Young Joseph
Thais Albert
Cousin Sabina
William David Witt
Man on the bench
William J. Mode
Pipe smoking tavern patron (uncredited)