Robert De Niro
Frank Sheeran
Joe Pesci
Russell Bufalino
Harvey Keitel
Angelo Bruno
Bobby Cannavale
Skinny Razor
Anna Paquin
Older Peggy Sheeran
Stephen Graham
Anthony "Tony Pro" Provenzano
Stephanie Kurtzuba
Irene Sheeran
Jack Huston
Robert Kennedy / RFK
Kathrine Narducci
Carrie Bufalino
Jesse Plemons
Chuckie O'Brien
Domenick Lombardozzi
Fat Tony Salerno
Paul Herman
Whispers DiTullio
Gary Basaraba
Frank "Fitz" Fitzsimmons
Marin Ireland
Older Dolores Sheeran
Lucy Gallina
Young Peggy Sheeran
Jonathan Morris
Assisted Living Priest
Welker White
Josephine "Jo" Hoffa
Sebastian Maniscalco
Crazy Joe Gallo
Aleksa Palladino
Mary Sheeran
Steven Van Zandt
Jerry Vale
Daniel H. Jenkins
E. Howard "Big Ears" Hunt
Kevin O'Rourke
John McCullough
Action Bronson
Casket Salesman
Glenn Cunningham
Investigator
Paul Ben-Victor
Jake Gottlieb
Patrick Gallo
Anthony "Tony Jack" Giacalone
James Martin
Mother of Sorrows Priest
Jake Hoffman
Allen Dorfman
Danny A. Abeckaser
Deadbeat
Anthony J. Gallo
Food Fair Manager
J.C. MacKenzie
Prosecutor Jim Neal
Jamil Antonio Stefan
Phil Testa
Joseph Riccobene
Jimmy "The Weasel" Fratianno
Vinny Vella
Meat Company Yard Manager
Thomas E. Sullivan
Warren Swanson
John Cenatiempo
Anthony "Tony 3 Fingers" Castellito
Robert Mladinich
Anastasia Bodyguard
Rich Reilly
Phil The Bartender
Robert Funaro
Johnny - Friendly Lounge
Tess Price
Young Maryanne Sheeran
Jennifer Mudge
Older Maryanne Sheeran
India Ennenga
Young Dolores
Jordyn DiNatale
Young Connie Sheeran
Kate Arrington
Older Connie Sheeran
Philip Suriano
Silver Shop Owner
Tony Suriano
Silver Shop Owner's Son
Jason A. Iannacone
German Prisoner #1
Michael C. Brennan
German Prisoner #2
James P. Harkins
John The Redhead
Al Linea
Sam "Momo" Giancana
Garry Pastore
Albert Anastasia
Frank Pietrangolare
Bartender - Friendly Lounge
Frank Aquilino
Friendly Lounge Guy "Butchie"
Johnny T. Sollitto
Friendly Lounge Patron
Patrick Murney
Peggy's Godfather
Samantha Soule
Peggy's Godmother
Richard V. Licata
Judge - Frank's First Trial
Vito Picone
Villa Roma Manager
Larry Mazza
Anastasia's Hitman #1
Craig DiFrancia
Anastasia's Hitman #2
Jon Bruno
Russell's Bodyguard
Paul Borghese
Mobster #1 - Curtain Shop
Steven Maglio
Mobster #2 - Curtain Shop / Copa Guest #1
James Licata
Mobster #3 - Curtain Shop
Veronica Alicino
Curtain Shop Staff #1
Mike Massimino
Curtain Shop Staff #2
James Ciccone
Anastasia Mobster in Car #1
Ron Castellano
Anastasia Mobster in Car #2
Meghan Rafferty
Bill Bufalino's Wife
James Lorinz
Hoffa Rally Teamster #1
Jeffrey Paul
Hoffa Rally Teamster #2
Robert C. Kirk
Hoffa Rally Teamster #3
Vince Maritato
Bathhouse Teamster
Rebecca Faulkenberry
Barbara Hoffa
Ken Wulf Clark
James P. Hoffa
John Rue
Senator McClellan
Steve Routman
Hoffa Attorney - George Fitzgerald
Fernando Vera
Castellito's Driver
Peter Claymore
Tough Teamster - Hoffa's Office
Charles DelGatto
Phil - Milestone Hauling
Michael Gongora
Cuban Worker
Eugene Bunge
Joseph Kennedy
Matthew F. O'Connor
Pro Rally Teamster #1
Cliff Moylan
Pro Rally Teamster #2
Vincenzo DelRiccio
Pro Rally Teamster #3
Steve Beauchamp
Pro Rally Teamster #4
Alfred Sauchelli, Jr.
Trucking Company Owner
Joe Giorgio
Local 326 Truck Driver
Diana Agostini
Ice Cream Shop Patron #1
Lauren Aparicio
Ice Cream Shop Patron #2
Kelley Rae O'Donnell
Ice Cream Shop Staff #1
John Garrett Greer
Ice Cream Shop Staff #2
Jack Caruso
Swanson's Booking Detective
John Scurti
Bertram B. Beveridge
Thomas J. Jenkins
Nashville Court Clerk
Steve Witting
Judge William Miller
Brent Langdon
Judge Frank Wilson
James D. Forsha
Tony Pro FBI Agent #1
Giacomino J. Matra
Tony Pro Guy #1
Paul Pearlman
Tony Pro Guy #2
Frank L. Messina
Tony Pro Guy #3
Cilda Shaur
Colombo's Wife
Dominick LaRuffa Jr.
Colombo's Son #1
Erick Zamora
Colombo's Son #2
Lou Martini Jr.
Copa Guest #3
Michael Bottari
Copa Guest #4
Margaret Anne Florence
Gallo's Wife Sina
Siena Marino
Gallo's Daughter Lisa
Lori Arkin
Gallo's Sister Carmella Fiorello
Nicholas Chrysan
Pete The Greek
Samantha Coppola
Pete The Greek's Girlfriend
Logan Crawford
Reporter at Prison
Jeff DeHart
President Nixon
Mark Fairchild
Attorney General Mitchell
Blaise Corrigan
Dave Johnson
Jill Brown
Dave Johnson's Wife
Matt Walton
TV Host / Moderator
Peter Jay Fernandez
NAACP President Cecil Moore
Stephen Mailer
District Attorney Emmett Fitzpatrick
Gino Cafarelli
Mayor Frank Rizzo
Robin Kerbis
Angelo Bruno's Wife
Lucia Giannetta
Tony Pro's Wife
Michael Romeo Ruocco
Casino Photographer
Amanda Kloots
Golddigger Dancer
Anne Horak
Golddigger Dancer
Brittany Bigelow
Golddigger Dancer
Vanessa Mitchell
Golddigger Dancer
Madison Eastman
Golddigger Dancer
Purdie Baumann
Golddigger Dancer
Jesse Wildman
Golddigger Dancer
Nina Lafarga
Golddigger Dancer
Neil Posner
Jerry Vale Band
Michael Leviton
Jerry Vale Band
Bridget Barkan
Jerry Vale Band
Andrea Weinzierl
Jerry Vale Band
Richard V. Pagano
Jerry Vale Band
Nicholas Wight
Jerry Vale Band
Joseph Russo
Bruno Denzetta
Barbara Eyland
Guest Dancing at Casino #1
Tracy J. Everitt
Guest Dancing at Casino #2
Saint Marino
Wedding Wise Guy #1
Mario Corry
Wedding Wise Guy #2
Johnny Potenza
Wedding Wise Guy #3
Joe Passaro
Wedding Wise Guy #4
Patrick Borriello
Wedding Wise Guy #5
Alfred Nittoli
Inmate Alfredo
David Aaron Baker
Assistant US Attorney
Stanley Burns
Colonoscopy Doctor
Bill Timoney
Prosecutor - Frank's 2nd Trial
Thomas J. McDonald
Deputy Clerk - Frank's 2nd Trial
Virl Andrick
Judge - Frank's 2nd Trial
Ernest L. Sanders Jr.
Frank's Orderly
Bill McHugh
Funeral Priest
Amelia Brain
Sales Girl at Crypt
Craig "Radioman" Castaldo
Man in Wheelchair
Michael Iacono
Bowler (uncredited)
Dean Ciallella
Italian Rally Supporter (uncredited)
Tommy Bayiokos
Truck Driver (uncredited)
Michael Cullum
Juror (uncredited)
Rick Bolander
Lewisburg Guard (uncredited)
Shade Rupe
Teamster (uncredited)
Ian Zelbo
Brother in Ice Cream Parlor (uncredited)
Jacqueline Kennedy
Self (archive footage)(uncredited)
John F. Kennedy
Self (archive footage)(uncredited)