Andrea Anders
Principal Hayes
Kyle Tristan
Christmas Pageant Kid
Daniel DiMaggio
Young Dusty
Matthew Delamater
Gun Salesman
Jose Guns Alves
Security Guard
John MacGregor
Improv Actor
Matthew Catanzano
Improv Actor
Molly Schreiber
Improv Actor
Jonathan Angel
Improv Audience Member
Jonathan Kobs
Nativity Instigator
Oscar Wahlberg
Roberto C. Fishman Pratt
Priscilla Manning
Brad's Mom
Chesley Sullenberger
Brad's Stepdad
Tony V.
Bowling Alley Employee
Allen Zwolle
Lonely Guy at Theatre
Marisa Pazik
Scotty Kimble's Mom
Bill Burr
Jerry (uncredited)
Liam Neeson
Liam Neeson (voice) (uncredited)
John Franchi
Pedestrian (uncredited)
Frankie Francois
Movie Theater Patron (uncredited)
Colton Osorio
Little Boy (uncredited)
Lance Norris
Hunter (uncredited)
Audrey Fratelli
Waitress (uncredited)
Jim Powers
Parent (uncredited)
Mary Hronicek
Movie Theater Patron (uncredited)
Susan Garfield
Lisa - Box Office Employee (uncredited)