John Robinson
Ronald 'Butch' DeFeo Jr.
Diane Franklin
Louise DeFeo
Paul Ben-Victor
Ronald DeFeo Sr.
Chelsea Ricketts
Dawn DeFeo
Eddie Alfano
Officer Aiello
Steve Trzaska
Randy Buechler
Rebekah Graf
Donna Benedettio
Sky Patterson
Steve Pelskie
Burt Young
Michael Brigante
Sarah French
Dawn's Girlfriend