All Cast

Mary Martin

Mary Martin

Peter Pan

Cyril Ritchard

Cyril Ritchard

Mr. Darling / Captain Hook

Lynn Fontanne

Lynn Fontanne

Narrator

Maureen Bailey

Maureen Bailey

Wendy / Jane

Margalo Gillmore

Margalo Gillmore

Mrs. Darling

Sondra Lee

Sondra Lee

Tiger Lily

Joe E. Marks

Joe E. Marks

Smee

Norman Shelly

Norman Shelly

Nana / Crocodile

Joey Trent

Joey Trent

John

Kent Fletcher

Kent Fletcher

Michael

Jacqueline Mayro

Jacqueline Mayro

Liza

Edmund Gaynes

Edmund Gaynes

Slightly

Bill Snowden

Bill Snowden

Curly

Carson Woods

Carson Woods

Nibs

Benedict Herrman

Benedict Herrman

First Twin

Luke Halpin

Luke Halpin

Second Twin

David Komoroff

David Komoroff

Tootles

Richard Wyatt

Richard Wyatt

Lion

Joan Tewkesbury

Joan Tewkesbury

Ostrich

Peggy Maurer

Peggy Maurer

Wendy Grown-up

John Holland

John Holland

Black Bill

Robert Vanselow

Robert Vanselow

Starkey

Richard Winter

Richard Winter

Cecco

George Zima

George Zima

Kangaroo

Frank Lindsay

Frank Lindsay

Pirate

Frank Marasco

Frank Marasco

Pirate

Arthur Partington

Arthur Partington

Pirate

Jim Sisco

Jim Sisco

Pirate

Kirby Smith

Kirby Smith

Pirate

John Smolko

John Smolko

Pirate

Arthur Tookoian

Arthur Tookoian

Pirate

James B. Welch

James B. Welch

Pirate

Linda Dangcil

Linda Dangcil

Indian

George Lake

George Lake

Indian

Lisa Lang

Lisa Lang

Indian

Diki Lerner

Diki Lerner

Indian

Annabelle Lyon

Annabelle Lyon

Indian

Robert Piper

Robert Piper

Indian

Suzanne Rivera

Suzanne Rivera

Indian

Anne Wallace

Anne Wallace

Indian

Jerry Johnson

Jerry Johnson

Pirate (uncredited)