All Cast
Tom Everett Scott
Nick Pearson
Tituss Burgess
The Amazing Fabular
Julian Feder
Mason
Rachel Boston
Sydney Bartlett
Rhea Seehorn
Kelly
Andrew Bowen
Richard
Julie Ann Emery
Joanna
Maria de Lourdes Severny
Carla Intinoli
Emily De Margheriti
Daisy
Arden Myrin
Janice Bodicker
Chris Levine
Winifred 'Winny'/Freddy
Marisa Tomei
Christine Hurley
Beth Riesgraf
Schyler Cross
Ray Abruzzo
Walter
Joyce Bulifant
Betty Bartlett
Roger Perry
Phil Bartlett
Bryan Batt
Reverend McGooley
Nathan Arenas
Frankie
Michael McHale
Deejay
Lewie Bartone
Chaz
Johnny Visotcky
Jimmy
Bo Foxworth
Dad
Jeris Poindexter
Attendant
Patrice Barrie
Old Annie
Rico E. Anderson
CHP Officer
Daisy Traina
Karate Girl
David Loden
Delivery Room Doctor
Tiffany Yvonne Cox
Delivery Room Nurse #1
Mary Hollis Inboden
Delivery Room Nurse #2
Todd Traina
Psychic #1
Kimberly Blair
Psychic #2
Rachel McHale
Psychic #3
John Landis
Psychic #4
Olivia Levine
Psychic #5
