All Cast
Kyle Davis
Jeff
Devin McGinn
Charlie
Gregg Lawrence
Captain Olaf
Edmund Lupinski
Professor Lake
Leah McKendrick
Chelsea
Richard Riehle
Mr. Snodgrass
Oren Skoog
Henry
Martin Starr
Clarence
Alexi Wasser
Nicole
Ethan Wilde
Starspawn
Jessica Kinney
Susie
Harry Karp
Jimbo
Douglas Jantzen Jr.
Cult Leader
Barak Hardley
Paul
Todd Duffey
Cult member #1
Sujata Day
Stacy Rahman
Justin Giddings
Comedic Cult Member #1
Bryce Hurless
Comic book kid