All Cast

Steve Guttenberg

Steve Guttenberg

Nicholas Claus

Crystal Bernard

Crystal Bernard

Elizabeth "Beth" Sawtelle

Dominic Scott Kay

Dominic Scott Kay

Jake Swatelle

Thomas Calabro

Thomas Calabro

Andrew

Armin Shimerman

Armin Shimerman

Ernest

Sebastian Tillinger

Sebastian Tillinger

Hennesy

Wendy Braun

Wendy Braun

Amy

Kelley Hazen

Kelley Hazen

Joanie

Mackenzie Fitzgerald

Mackenzie Fitzgerald

Jocelyn

Cody Arens

Cody Arens

Christian

Robin Shorr

Robin Shorr

Meredith

John Wheeler

John Wheeler

Santa

Taffy Wallace

Taffy Wallace

Coach

Samantha Bennett

Samantha Bennett

Marilyn

Ashlynn Bernard

Ashlynn Bernard

Young Beth

Katia Coe

Katia Coe

Holly

Clement von Franckenstein

Clement von Franckenstein

Sir John

Marcia Ann Burrs

Marcia Ann Burrs

Mrs. Clauss

Miranda Gibson

Miranda Gibson

Emily

Hannah Wilber

Hannah Wilber

Hearing Impaired Girl

Austin Miles

Austin Miles

Mall Santa

Darby Stanchfield

Darby Stanchfield

Store Clerk

Diane Robin

Diane Robin

Woman Customer

Erik Carr

Erik Carr

Connor

Alison McMillan

Alison McMillan

Mom of Hearing Impaired Girl

Frank Sharp

Frank Sharp

Tree Seller

Brandon Keener

Brandon Keener

Commercial 1st AD

Mariette Hartley

Mariette Hartley

Joanna

Staci Armao

Staci Armao

(Uncredited / voice)

Blaise Brooks

Blaise Brooks

Basketball Fan (uncredited)

S. Zev Esquenazi

S. Zev Esquenazi

Production Assistant (uncredited)

Dassler Jimenez

Dassler Jimenez

Elf (uncredited)

David Rasner

David Rasner

Various Voices (uncredited)