All Cast

Sadie Sink

Sadie Sink

Ziggy Berman

Emily Rudd

Emily Rudd

Cindy Berman

Ryan Simpkins

Ryan Simpkins

Alice

McCabe Slye

McCabe Slye

Tommy Slater

Gillian Jacobs

Gillian Jacobs

C. Berman / Adult Ziggy

Kiana Madeira

Kiana Madeira

Deena

Benjamin Flores Jr.

Benjamin Flores Jr.

Josh

Ted Sutherland

Ted Sutherland

Young Nick Goode

Meghan Packer

Meghan Packer

TV Anchor

Matthew Zuk

Matthew Zuk

Mayor Will Goode

Olivia Scott Welch

Olivia Scott Welch

Sam Fraser

Brandon Spink

Brandon Spink

Young Will Goode

Chiara Aurelia

Chiara Aurelia

Sheila

Marcelle LeBlanc

Marcelle LeBlanc

Becky

Eden Campbell

Eden Campbell

Annie

Michael Provost

Michael Provost

Kurt

Drew Scheid

Drew Scheid

Gary

Jacqi Vene

Jacqi Vene

Joan

Sam Brooks

Sam Brooks

Arnie

Jordana Spiro

Jordana Spiro

Nurse Mary Lane

Jason Edwards

Jason Edwards

Sunnyvale Cop

Paul Teal

Paul Teal

Young Officer Kapinski

Alex Huff

Alex Huff

Mean Sunnyvale Jailer

Dylan Gage

Dylan Gage

Jeremy

Jayden Griffin

Jayden Griffin

Cool Sunnyvale Camper

Jordyn DiNatale

Jordyn DiNatale

Ruby Lane

Kevin Waterman

Kevin Waterman

'The Milkman' Harry Rooker

Emily Brobst

Emily Brobst

Billy Barker

Keil Oakley Zepernick

Keil Oakley Zepernick

'Shame Killer' Isaac Milton

Michael Chandler

Michael Chandler

'The Pastor' Cyrus Miller

Lana Spraley

Lana Spraley

Shadyside Prisoner #1

Ja'rell Anderson

Ja'rell Anderson

Shadyside Prisoner #2

Elizabeth Scopel

Elizabeth Scopel

Sarah Fier

Kenneth Trujillo

Kenneth Trujillo

EMT

Ashley Zukerman

Ashley Zukerman

Sheriff Nick Goode

Julia Rehwald

Julia Rehwald

Kate Schmidt (archive footage)

Fred Hechinger

Fred Hechinger

Simon Kalivoda (archive footage)

Christopher Talbert

Christopher Talbert

Crying camper