All Cast
Lacey Chabert
Tess Harper
Brennan Elliott
Logan O'Connor
Barbara Niven
Aunt Candace
John Kapelos
Chief Chauncey O'Connor
Romaine Waite
Winston Sams
Lara Jean Chorostecki
Christina Blake
Alex Paxton-Beesley
Abby Miller
Kimberly J. Brown
Angela
Kyle Buchanan
Lyle Clark
Lindsay Owen Pierre
Emory Nelson
Genevieve Kang
Josephine
Janet Porter
Bethany
Kintaro Akiyama
Elliot
Will Shortz
Police Officer
Richard Ashton
Richards the Diamond Dealer
Jeffrey R. Smith
Baxter the Farmer
Josette Jorge
Librarian
Carrie Schiffler
Clerk
Racine Bebamikawe
Nurse Bethany
Jason Diaz
Clayton
Brenda Robins
Mildred Clark
Hannah Kanter
Student Worker
Bobby Daniels
Minister