All Cast
Ema Horvath
Alex
Yeardley Smith
Sarah
John Ales
Carey
Alyssa Milano
Judith
Siddharth Dhananjay
Rohan
Reid Miller
Arthur
Peter Parros
Reggie
Devon Sawa
Karl
Kiah Butts
Nancy
Keziah Wall
Eliza
Delyn Wall
Rose
Jenna Louie Lohouse
Gayle
Duffy Epstein
Beau
Jeanine Jackson
Substitute Teacher
Lauren Wafer
Mean Girl
Elizabeth Huffman
Headmistress
Rob Nelson
Lyft Driver
Laura Duyn
Minister
Wolfie Beacham
Delivery Guy
Suzanne Owens-Duval
Grandmother
Ayanna Berkshire
Therapist
A. Brian Daniels
Party Guest
A. Brian Daniels
Party Guest
Xzavier Beacham
Pizza Guy
Carlo Hernandez
Church Couple (Man)
Naomi Klockars
Student
Debbie Marr
Church Member