All Cast
Judd Nelson
Pastor Wember
Brian Baumgartner
Skip Wick
Rhoda Griffis
Donna
Claire Bronson
Rebekah
Shawn Parsons
Chris Angelopolous
Gunner Willis
Cliff
Shua Jackson
Roadie
Michael H. Cole
Jack
Sandra Elise Williams
Mimi
Jef Holbrook
Snarky Fan
Andrew Eakle
Erik
Caleb Hoffmann
Scotty
Shannon Hutchinson
Sarah
Wyatt Lenhart
Michael
Matt Hoffman
Adult Erik
Blaque Fowler
Drunk Rocker
Alan Wells
Perry Minter
Lilly Nelson
Meg
Christina Leidel
Amy Grant
James Edward Thomas
Adult Cliff
Miles Snow
Dean Wilkie
Pete Penuel
Adult Michael
Laticia Lee
Bartender