Justin Hartley
Jacob Turner
Barrett Doss
Rachel Campbell
Bonnie Bedelia
Ellie Foster
Essence Atkins
Noel Hayden
Aaron Costa Ganis
Matt Segreto
Lucia Spina
Book Store Owner
Shelby Reitman Renee
Young Noel
Whitney Kimball Long
Attractive Fan
Monica McCarthy
Lois Turner
Baylen D. Bielitz
Benjamin Turner
Hollis Kempain Abram
Townsfolk
Marilyn Busch
Fifty-Something Fan
Kathleen Mary Carthy
Candlelight Inn Receptionist