All Cast

Jennie Garth

Jennie Garth

Susan

Brad Rowe

Brad Rowe

Jake

Tom Arnold

Tom Arnold

Pat

Nikki Cox

Nikki Cox

Cheri (voice)

Jay Mohr

Jay Mohr

Rusty (voice)

Catherine Hicks

Catherine Hicks

Ellen

David O'Donnell

David O'Donnell

Frank

Miles Elliot

Miles Elliot

Logan Davis

Ellee Jo Trowbridge

Ellee Jo Trowbridge

Emma

Conrad Bluth

Conrad Bluth

Josh

John Colton

John Colton

Reverend Paul

Shawn Ardalan

Shawn Ardalan

Elf

Keith Dobbins

Keith Dobbins

Santa Claus

Brock Burnett

Brock Burnett

Rainbow

Shirell Ferguson-Coleman

Shirell Ferguson-Coleman

Tahira

Ariana Brown

Ariana Brown

Thelma

Brad Barnholtz

Brad Barnholtz

Chauncey

Michael Healey

Michael Healey

Troy / Ziggy