All Cast
Angela Mariano
Sarah
Rick Edwards
Father Jake
Greg Sestero
David
Louisa Torres
Erika
Jesse Brenneman
Scott
Zhubin Rahbar
Sam
Tom Franco
Brooks
Chris Seidman
Truman
R.J. Cantu
Border Patrol
Sananda Vietor
Motorcyclist
Hannah Mouton
Cher
Alison Skiadas
Voice on Phone / News Anchor
Jessica Cobb
Silver Pines Nurse
Björgvin Franz Gíslason
News Reporter
Cindy Owensby
Woman in Church #1
Coralie Jean Philipe
Woman in Church #2
Tom Franco
Cult Member
Aaron Hart
Cult Member
Benjamin Tarshish
Cult Member
Ethan Tarshish
Cult Member
Jeremy Ambler
Cult Member
Jen Figueroa
Cult Member