All Cast
Aubrey Plaza
Darius Britt
Basil Harris
Restaurant Manager
Mary Lynn Rajskub
Bridget Bay
Jake Johnson
Jeff Schwensen
Karan Soni
Arnau
David Leo
Coworker (as David Leo Schultz)
Jeff Garlin
Mr. Britt
Mark Duplass
Kenneth Calloway
William Hall Jr.
Shannon
Alice Hung
Shift Manager
Jenica Bergere
Liz McHollis
Lynn Shelton
Uptight Mom
Eli Borozan
Kid in Diner
Tom Ricciardelli
Security Guard
Tony Doupe
Smith
Xola Malik
Jones
Grace Arends
Darcy
Kimberly Durham
Linsey
Scott Swan
Halloween
