Dustin Hoffman
Captain Hook
Robin Williams
Peter Banning / Peter Pan
Phil Collins
Inspector Good
René González Jr.
Additional Lost Boy
Brian Willis
Additional Lost Boy
Brett Willis
Additional Lost Boy
Max Hoffman
5-Year-Old Peter Pan
Kelly Rowan
Peter's Mother
Shannon Marie Kies
Mermaid
Regina Russell Banali
Mermaid
Jewel Newlander Hubbard
Peter Pan in Play
Jeannine Renshaw
Drama Teacher
Rebecca Hoffman
Jane in Play
Francesca Serrano
Lost Boy in Play
Kevin Gasca
Lost Boy in Play
Andre Bollinger
Lost Boy in Play
Lauren Friedler-Gow
Lost Boy in Play
Bryce Armstrong
Lost Boy in Play
Margie Takeda
Lost Boy in Play
Alyson Healing
Lost Boy in Play
Zoe Koehler
Lost Boy in Play
Jake Hoffman
Little League Player
Brenda Isaacs Booth
Secretary
Gwyneth Paltrow
Young Wendy
Mary Bond Davis
Prostitute
Matthew Van Ginkel
Baby Peter Banning
Kim Robillard
Toothless Cripple
Michael Runyard
Screaming Pirate
Gary Epper
Growling Pirate
Jeff Bornstein
Pirate (uncredited)
Carrie Fisher
Woman Kissing on Bridge (uncredited)
George Lucas
Man Kissing on Bridge (uncredited)
Jimmy Buffett
Shoe-Stealing Pirate (uncredited)