Billy Crystal
Artie Decker
Marisa Tomei
Alice Simmons
Tom Everett Scott
Phil Simmons
Bailee Madison
Harper Simmons
Joshua Rush
Turner Simmons
Kyle Breitkopf
Barker Simmons
Jennifer Crystal Foley
Cassandra
Corey James Wright
Drayton Glass
Justin R. Kennedy
Brad Zolick
Fyodor Cherniavsky
Orchestra Conductor
Ron Clinton Smith
Umpire Clark
Nate Panning
Coach Bostick
Kendra Goehring-Garnett
Doris Halloran
Troy Michael Simeon
Parker
Daniel Fridkin
Chet Halloran
Ralph Branca
Legendary Judge
Brett Cooper
Speech Student (uncredited)