All Cast
Mark Bischoff
Lulu's On Main Customer
Alix Kermes
Lynn Travis
Michael Bonini
Peter Menold
Jason Frederick
Pierce Morton
Catherine Cain
Julie Remington
Stefanie Bloom
Madison Bell
David Otunga
Coach Robinson
Allison Grischow
Lulu Davis
Kenney Myers
Mayor Jeff Kaufman
Katelin Stack
Mae Kaufman
Jeff Timmons
Pastor Mark
Ivana Grahovac
Brooke Remington
Collin Weigle
Bake-Off Attendee
Adam Smith
Lulu's On Main Customer
James Julah
Bake-Off Attendee