Billy Crystal
Dr. Ben Sobel
Lisa Kudrow
Laura MacNamara Sobel
Chazz Palminteri
Primo Sidone
Kresh Novakovic
'50s Gangster
Bart Tangredi
Young Vitti, Sr.
Michael Straka
Young Dominic Manetta
Joseph Rigano
Dominic Manetta
Richard C. Castellano
Jimmy Boots
Rebecca Schull
Dorothy Sobel
Pat Cooper
Salvatore Masiello
Jimmie Ray Weeks
FBI Agent Steadman
William Hill
FBI Agent Provano
Ira Wheeler
Scott MacNamara
Luce Ennis
Belinda MacNamara
Elizabeth Bracco
Marie Vitti
Gina Gallagher
Theresa Vitti
Vinny Vella, Jr.
Anthony Vitti
Mickey Bruno
Miami Soldier
Dave Corey
Miami Hall Guard
Fred Workman
Justice of the Peace
Daniel W. Barringer
Dream Sequence Gunman
John Polce
Dream Sequence Gunman
Drew Eliot
Priest at Funeral
Grace DeSena
Tommy Angels' Widow
New York Joe Catalfumo
Exuberant Mourner
Michael Guarino, Jr.
Stevie Beef
Michael Harkins
Paretti's Family
Paula Raflo
Paretti's Family
Ondine Harris
Paretti's Family
Matthew Vega
Paretti's Family
Clem Caserta
Handsome Jack
Judith Kahan
Elaine Felton
Pasquale Cajano
Joe Baldassare
Gene Ruffini
Frankie Zello
Alfred Sauchelli, Jr.
Mo-Mo
Tony DiBenedetto
Johnny "Bigs"
Frank Aquilino
Eddie "Cokes"
Joseph Bonanno
Joseph Bonanno (archive footage)
Joe Gallo
Joe Gallo (archive footage)
Kenny Alfonso
Car Chase Driver (uncredited)
Phillip V. Caruso
Wedding Photographer (uncredited)
Anthony Caso
Johnny Angel (uncredited)
Richard D'Alessandro
Gangster (uncredited)
Trish Dempsey
Hotel Guest (uncredited)
Tony Devon
Bobby Angel (uncredited)
Benim Foster
SWAT Team Leader (uncredited)
Russell Gibson
Mafio Capo (uncredited)
Joseph Hardin
Man in Commercial (uncredited)
James Morricone
Wise Guy (uncredited)
Michael Rothberger
Soldier (uncredited)
Paul Scannapieco
Freddie the Fruitman (uncredited)
Vinny Vella
Mobster at Meeting (uncredited)