All Cast
Misha Collins
Paul Bernardo
Laura Prepon
Karla Homolka
Brandon Routh
Tim
Patrick Bauchau
Dr. Arnold
Emilie Jacobs
Debbie
Adam Lieberman
Detective Morgan
Shawn Hoffman
Detective Steve Kirby
William Duffy
Detective Porter
Alex Boyd
Nick
Cherilyn Hayres
Tammy Homolka
Kristen Honey
Tina McCarthy (as Kristen Swieconek)
Cole James
Tina's Friend
Carole Ita White
Waitress
Fiona Manners
Rape Victim #1
Tanya Lemelle
Rape Victim #2
Tony Shawkat
Border Guard #1
Tess Harper
Molly
Leonard Kelly-Young
Dan
Anna Pheil
Patricia
Zach DiLiberto
Doug
Nikki McCauley
Jessie
Sarah Foret
Kaitlyn Ross
Tony Denison
Detective Burroughs
Jeff Doucette
Burroughs's Partner
Bunny Gibson
Mrs. Ross
Bradford English
Mr. Ross
John Ross Clark
Attorney Warner
Philippe Bergeron
Attorney Siegel
Eileen Dietz
Helen
